The Int. Law Observer Blog is continuously looking for enthusiastic master student(s) or Ph.D. candidate(s) willing to assist with editorial work on the Blog. Interested? Find out more here.

Home » Public International Law, United Nations

Kosovo declares independence

Submitted by on 18/02/2008 – 12:35 pmOne Comment

The Kosovo parliament declared on 17 February 2008 Kosovo’s independence. This post attempts to dissect Kosovo’s declaration from international law point of view.

United Nations Security Council established the current status of Kosovo on 10 June 1999 and placed it under the temporary administration of the United Nations Mission in Kosovo, under the leadership of a Special Representative of the Secretary General (U.N. Security Council Resolution 1244, 10 June 1999). It also explicitly upheld the existing sovereignty of Serbia over Kosovo, reaffirming the commitment of all Member States to the sovereignty and territorial integrity of the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia and the other States of the region. In this line, Belgrade proposed that Kosovo be highly autonomous and remain a part of Serbia; Belgrade officials have repeatedly said that an imposition of Kosovo’s independence would be a violation of Serbia’s sovereignty and therefore contrary to international law. That said, the 1998-1999 Kosovo conflict left some 10,000 Kosovo Albanians dead and forced about 800,000 to flee their homes. Today, there are about 100,000 ethnic Serbs still living in the province, where the ethnic Albanian majority accounts for 90 per cent of its population of two million. Albanian dominated Kosovo parliament in Priština therefore declared Kosovo’s independence, arguing that the violence of the Miloševic years has made continued union between Kosovo and Serbia not viable.

The Community which claims the right to self-determination has to fulfil certain objective criteria: they have to be perceived by themselves and by the world as the people, the nation; this is fulfilled by the common history, language and culture. They have to live on the particular territory in an organized and united way – presumably being a majority of the inhabitants. They have to exercise control over the territory. If this territory is a part of the larger state structure where the majority in the entire state (as opposed to this particular territory) has for a very long time breached their fundamental rights – just because they are a different ethnic group – then this is another compelling reason towards the fulfilment of conditions of the right to self-determination.

Kosovo Albanians fulfil those conditions: they are of a particular ethnicity, with their own language, culture and history and are perceived as such by themselves as well as by the Serbs and the rest of the world. Also they form a big majority in a clearly defined territory, which is under their de facto control. They exercise local government; they have schools, universities and have had all these for decades now. In fact and a fortiori they were even recognized as an autonomous region within Serbia during former Yugoslavia, which just strengthens their case. This autonomy was abandoned against their will in the time of Milosevic’s totalitarian regime. But this was just an apex of the violations of their fundamental political as well as human rights that have lasted since the mid 1980s.  Having said that, in my normative view based on the coherent analysis of legal and factual practice there is not a single shadow of doubt that Albanians in Kosovo have fulfilled the conditions for the right to self-determination. Serbia can have no say on that, if the right to self-determination is destined to have any sense.

It is submitted that the issues of self-determination and creation of states in international law and international relations have always been much more political than they are legal questions. Some would argue that, the creation of a state is a political act, and legal justifications are usually realizations of what has happened in reality. There was once no state of Slovenia, but now there is, and the law has little to do with it. All in all, it is argued that Kosovo’s parliament, made a right decision in unanimously declaring independence from Serbia, and by doing so established the newest state on the European continent. Now real work for Kosovo state only begins.

Last 5 posts by Jernej Letnar Černič
Tags: , , , , ,